HMS EXETER: A SURVIVOR’S
ACCOUNT
By
AT King RMB X1136
Dear Editor
Some time ago whilst taking part in an RMA (City of London
Branch) annual visit to Zeebrugge to commemorate the 1918
raid, a former member of the RMSM (Ron Coe) gave to me a copy
of Blue Band (Winter 1983/4 edition) which contains an article
written by Major JM McMahon RM officer in charge of the RM
detachment of HMS Exeter during the period 1941 - 1945. The
article deals specifically with the tragic death of Bandmaster
Victor Vidler in a Far Eastern POW camp. As a survivor of
the RM band of the Exeter I had already read that article,
Major McMahon had shown me a copy of it some years previously
at an HMS Exeter re-union, but re-reading it has prompted
me to relate the story of the RM band of HMS Exeter, as far
as I recall after 60+ years. The recent publication “The Royal
Marine Band Service” (Page 57) contains an account mainly
of Bandmaster Vidler’s part and untimely death in the prison
camps. A copy of that book, kindly autographed by the present
Director of Music, Lt Col. CJ Davis, was presented to me,
as, probably the sole survivor of the Band of the Exeter,
at the 2004 annual re-union of the ship’s survivors, by two
cousins of Victor Vidler, Bill and Peter Cox, Peter’s wife
Brenda, and the daughter of the late Major McMahon, Mrs Maeve
McMahon-Hercod. There were five deaths among the fifteen bandsmen
of Exeter, five who died in as tragic circumstances as those
of our servicemen who died in sinking ships while battened
down in a TS, for all died as a result of enemy action and
that which follows is an account of how we bandsmen of the
Exeter coped under very trying, arduous conditions for three
and a half years, of the deaths of our five mess-mates, and
of those who survived to return home.
Yours sincerely
AT King RMB X1136
Royal Naval School of Music, Malvern, 1940
Orders to form a Band for HMS Exeter given to:-
Bandmaster Victor Vidler
Band Corporal Bill Hartley clarinet & violin
Musicians Alan Dodds basses
Johnny Buckle cornet & violin
Harry Bance euphonium & cello
Andy Beveridge percussion
Archie Bowler clarinet, viola & cymbals
Terry Butcher solo cornet
Stan Thomas solo clarinet
Hedley Adams saxophone & violin
Ken Cayser saxophone & violin
Ted Jones flute, piano & bass drum
Frank Harris cornet & violin
Doug Wilkins clarinet & violin
And me trombone
The Band remained at Malvern for a few weeks, getting to
know each other, with a visit for a few days to the Royal
Naval Gunnery School at HMS Excellent, Whale Island, Portsmouth,
for a TS refresher course, returning to Malvern for a short
while.
 |
|
A stormy passage on HMS Exeter ©Royal Marines Museum |
Then to a Royal Naval Training School, HMS Impregnable, at
St Budeaux, Plymouth, during the winter 1940/41, carrying
out band duties, until Exeter was ready for sea. The Band
then embarked on Exeter and set sail in March 1941 for Scapa
Flo to carry out sea trials on completion of which Exeter
proceeded to Greenoch on the River Clyde, to collect a convoy
for the North Africa campaign via Cape of Good Hope. During
mid 1941, the ship was escorting convoys in the Indian Ocean
to the Red Sea, until Dec 41 when the Far East became a theatre
of war. Convoys were then essential to India and Singapore
and, in Jan 42, Exeter passed through the Sunda Straits (in
sight of the shattered peak of Krakatoa) to the seas around
Singapore and the then Dutch East Indies (now Indonesia),
where Exeter joined the Combined Allied Fleet under the command
of the Dutch Admiral Doormann. There was constant harassment
from Japanese aircraft. On one occasion, Exeter scared off
the enemy by firing a salvo from it’s two forward twin 8 turrets
at a formation of fighter-bombers heading for the Exeter and
accompanying ships. About this time Terry Butcher fell ill
with severe abdominal pains, appendicitis was suspected and
he was put ashore in Singapore for hospital treatment. He
was left behind in Singapore, eventually escaping from the
turmoil of the Japanese invasion of that island, and returning
to Britain. That left Exeter with an RM Band of 14. The Japanese
progressed South through the East Indies and by end of February
42 were threatening Java and at that stage the Combined Fleet
joined battle with a large Japanese fleet, and on 27 February
the main Battle of the Java Sea was fought during which Exeter
was severely damaged when an 8 shell hit one of the starboard
twin 4AA gun and continued down into B boiler room putting
six boilers out of action and reducing the ship’s speed greatly,
as a result of which Exeter fell out of line and effectively
out of that battle. Exeter returned to Surabaya in Java to
bury its dead crew members and effect repairs to the damaged
areas of the ship, remaining in Surabaya until the evening
of 28 February when the ship set sail, together with two destroyers,
HMS Encounter and the USS Pope, intending to attempt an escape
route through the Sunda Straits to Colombo. At that time these
three ships were all that remained of the Allied Combined
Fleet in the Java Sea, most of the ships in the fleet having
been sunk. On 1 March, in the afternoon, enemy ships (four
cruisers and three destroyers) were sighted and the ensuing
battle resulted in all three of the Allied ships being sunk.
The RM band in the TS of Exeter all managed to escape from
the sinking ship and together with other survivors of that
action, were taken prisoner by the enemy and spent the next
three years six months in captivity. Many books have been
written by Far Eastern POWs, telling of the hardships endured;
inadequate food, negligible medical supplies to combat the
maladies which fell upon us, dysentery, malaria, beriberi
and so on, the beatings by ferocious guards, the incessant
hard physical labour, and, for we survivors of the sea battle,
no personal possessions other than the few clothes we were
wearing at the time. In my case, a pair of underpants, a KSD
shirt and KSD shorts, and a pair of slip on shoes. (The shoes
were lost as soon as I jumped off the side of the ship into
the Java sea and the wash of the ship, still underway, whipped
the shoes off from my feet). Some of the crew were picked
up by a Japanese destroyer on the same day, but the majority,
me included, spent a night and half the next day huddled on
carley floats and balsa rafts before the Japanese sent a ship
to collect us. Eventually, we of the Exeter, Encounter and
Pope found ourselves in Macassar, on the Celebes Islands.
The RM band tried to keep together as best we could, however,
later in 1942, two, Alan Dodds and Stan Thomas, were included
in a working party which was transported to Japan. We were
then twelve RMB members at Macassar.
 |
|
HMS Exeter 1941 ©Royal Marines Museum
|
Due to the poor diet we had to endure, our physical condition
deteriorated quite rapidly and coupled with attacks of malaria,
for there were no mosquito nets in that tropical ‘Butlins’,
and most inmates succumbing to dysentery, deaths began to
occur among all sections of the camp, British, Dutch and Americans.
In 1943 a large party of Brits were detailed off to form a
working party in a nickel quarry in Pamella, a day’s journey
by ship to the other side of the Celebes. Among that party
were Johnny Buckle and Doug Wilkins. Major McMahon was the
senior officer in charge of that party, and the survivors
speak very highly of the way in which he administered the
delicate situation between the Japanese and the POWs. The
party was away from Macassar for some eight months, and when
the survivors returned to Macassar, Johnny and Doug were not
among them, they had both died, Johnny of dysentery aggravated
by malaria and Doug of septicaemia, occasioned by tropical
ulcers caused by injuries sustained at the quarry work. Then
we were ten RM Bandsmen remaining at Macassar.
Throughout the remaining months of 1943 we struggled to survive
on our daily meagre rations of boiled rice and ‘greens’ (mainly
edible leaves somewhat similar to watercress) supplemented
by whatever we could scrounge while out of camp on working
parties, such as unripe mangos bananas and bits of coconut
etc. Harry ‘Knocker’ Bance, our euphonium/cello player, was
the next to fall extremely ill, appearing to lose all energy
and will to carry on in the fight to survive. He died in the
camp sick bay after falling into a coma.
We were then nine in Macassar, determined to see it through
to the end and to freedom. But in 1945, only a few short months
before victory over the Japanese, we had two more of our number
pass on.
First, Bandy Vidler, in April 1945 died of beriberi. I saw
him just before he died, as I, too, was carried into the camp
hospital with the same illness. Bandy was in an advanced stage
of the illness and never recovered. In the hospital hut at
the time was Frank Harris, struck down with an abdominal illness,
weak with dysentery, and all hope gone. I was with him to
the end.
So we ended the war with seven RMB survivors at Macassar,
not knowing what had become of our two comrades in Japan,
Allen Dodds and Stan Thomas. Fortunately, they also had survived,
so, eventually nine returned to the UK out of the 14 taken
into captivity.
The two in Japan returned home courtesy of the US navy and
airforce.
The seven of us from Macassar were taken by the RN to Freemantle
in Western Australia, from where five returned home on HMS
Maidstone in 1945. Two of us, Bill Hartley and I remained
in hospital, me in Perth and Bill in another hospital in the
country. It was not until early March 1946 that I finally
set foot in England again, five years since the Exeter sailed
out of Plymouth with its RM Band of fifteen.
I have since learned, over the years, of the deaths of seven
of the nine survivors of the original fourteen captured in
1942. Terry Butcher (the one who had managed to escape captivity)
died aged 86. Only Ted Jones, who I last saw in hospital in
Perth, Australia, in 1945, has ‘gone missing’. I do not know
where he is, or whether, he too, has passed on. (If you are
still around Ted, and you happen to read this, please get
in touch).
As the years have gone by, I have thought constantly of those
five shipmates who never returned to Britain from that prison
camp in Macassar. Every November, on Remembrance Sunday, and
on 15 August (VJ Day), as I stand at the Cenotaph in Whitehall
during the two minutes silence, I recite their names in my
head, and remember those other crew members of HMS Exeter
who never returned, some of whose names I can still recall.
During the Naval Actions of 27 February and 1 March, 58 lives
were lost from Exeter’s crew (including 7 Royal Marines) and
in the ensuing three and a half years of captivity a further
144 died (including 18 Royal Marines).

A TS Table Image ©Royal Marines Museum
|